For Sale 1621 New York, Cape May, NJ, 08204

AMAZING RENTAL PROPERTY WITH AN IN-GROUND POOL! Over $240,000 of gross income in 2025! This property is the perfect Cape May Modern Beach House with a Heated IN GROUND Pool with a rare and desirable sun shelf as well as a Heated Front Porch for extended outdoor enjoyment!! This newly finished 5-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom house is a splendid home, rental property or retreat for today\'s discriminating Buyer. The open concept first floor has elegant, coffered ceilings, a nine-foot island with beverage fridge, gas fireplace and gorgeous fixtures. There is a spacious dining area, and the adorable powder room is fabulous. The back lounge has a bar that looks into the kitchen and also has a wonderful view of the pool and outside entertainment area. The interior design is bright and motivating. The First Floor Primary Bedroom with a gorgeous Primary Bath is sought after in this market. The Second Floor has another Primary Bedroom with ensuite bathroom to help maximize rental income and guest comforts. The multipurpose Den on the second floor can be an office, living room, workout area and more. There are three other nice sized guest bedrooms and a full bath on the second floor. The 1.5 car garage allows for that extra room for beach gear and bikes. The irrigated landscaping and pavers enhance the beauty of this impeccable property. The Sellers thought of everything, even a whole house generator! This is a turnkey property, less Sellers\' personal items. Call for your appointment today!!!

Welcome to this exquisite multi-level residence, gracefully situated on a spacious 0.23-acre corner lot in the highly desirable Cape May Beach community. Just two blocks from the serene shores of the Delaware Bay—with direct beach access at the end of Fern Road—this home beautifully marries coastal elegance with timeless Craftsman and modern farmhouse design. Spanning approximately 2,200 square feet, the open-concept interior offers four bedrooms and three and a half baths, thoughtfully designed to accommodate both everyday living and effortless entertaining. The entry level welcomes you with a generous foyer featuring whimsical tile flooring, tongue-and-groove wood panel accents, and dedicated coat and shoe closets. Anderson casement windows frame natural light throughout, enhanced by rich dark walnut pre-engineered hardwood floors. From the foyer, step into a warm, inviting family room anchored by a wood-burning pellet stove (2024). Adjacent, a light-filled all-seasons sunroom—currently used as a playroom—provides a seamless indoor-outdoor living experience. A private in-law or guest suite with its own en-suite bath and a discreet pocket door offers both comfort and privacy for extended family or visitors as well as a conveniently located separate powder room. On the main level, sunlight pours into the heart of the home—a beautifully integrated living, dining, and kitchen space. The dining area features custom-built corner banquette seating, while the kitchen exudes understated luxury with white cabinetry, a striking quartz waterfall island, tile backsplash, and premium stainless appliances. The upper level is home to a serene primary suite, complete with a walk-in closet and a spa-inspired bath featuring a soaking tub, separate glass-enclosed shower, and dual vanities. A thoughtfully placed office with a built-in desk for two creates the perfect work-from-home retreat. Two additional bedrooms share a stylish full bathroom, while the nearby second-floor laundry room—with ample linen storage—adds to the home\'s functional ease. Storage is abundant throughout, including multiple closets and a spacious walk-up attic with standing room. All major systems—mechanical, plumbing, and electrical—as well as all appliances (including washer and dryer), have been updated within the past three years. Step outside to enjoy a private Trex back deck and a beautifully paved front patio. The backyard is a blank canvas, awaiting your vision for a pool, garden, or custom outdoor retreat. A detached two-story garage—climate-controlled with mini-split systems on both floors—features a vaulted bonus room above, currently used as a home gym or ideal for a studio space or guest quarters. Modern conveniences abound, including a dual-zoned Sonos sound system (indoor/outdoor), Nest thermostats, a Nest video doorbell, and an EV charging station. Ideally located just a five-minute walk to the bay and ten minutes from the expansive Cox Hall Creek Wildlife Sanctuary—featuring over 200 acres of trails, birdwatching, and a stocked pond—this home is a rare blend of nature, comfort, and refined living. More than a home, this is a lifestyle—an inspired retreat in one of Cape May Beach’s most treasured settings. Move-in ready, beautifully appointed, and thoughtfully designed, this exceptional property is ready to welcome you. *furnishings minus personals and the entire twin bedroom negotiable.

Nestled in the dunes overlooking the Delaware Bay in Cape May Beach with a new sunset drawn out every night. This isn’t just any beach property—this is one of the few remaining homes with untouched, naturally protected dunes on the bay side of New Jersey preserving the raw, unspoiled coastal experience—which adds long-term prestige and aesthetic value This 3 level home offers views from all rooms after it was expanded and modernized inside and out in 2011.The first floor features an open tiled foyer with storage and an oversized garage with a finished epoxy floor. The second floor has a wet bar and entertaining area, 3 bedrooms with access to a screened porch overlooking the bay. The top floor is breathtaking as you enter and see water as far as the eye can see. The top level has vaulted ceilings, and a window lined great room and primary suite that connect to a spacious deck. The calm and joy you have every time you see the water is priceless. Coastal Living begins here with dolphins, eagles and sunsets all in your back yard. Modern open kitchen with LG Signature appliances, granite counters, 2 sinks, wine cooler. Living area with gas fireplace. 2 zone gas heat/ and air with additional split in primary and radiant floor in foyer. 2 washers and dryers. Pumpkin pine wood flooring. Bulkhead across the front of the property. Property is monitored by a security system so all appointments must be scheduled. Seller selling furniture with a separate Bill of Sale $100,000. Open houses are scheduled Saturday 12th and 19th 10:30 to 1:30.